New Vs Old | Soap & Glory Sexy Mother Pucker Lipsticks

Monday, June 13, 2016

review new soap & glory lipsticks


I don't think I've ever recovered from the moment I heard the rumour that Soap & Glory would be discontinuing my beloved original Sexy Mother Pucker Lipsticks nÊe Super Colour Fabu Lipsticks. I've made no secret of the fact that they are some of my favourite lipsticks, among them being Naked Beige, the only lipstick I've ever used up in its entirety. I finally found some closure though and I recently picked up a couple of the newly launched lipsticks, bearing the same name. And now I'm here to tell you how I feel they compare to their predecessors.


soap and glory lipstick review naked beige


The original Soap & Glory Sexy Mother Pucker Lipsticks | review came in 2 finishes with 3 shades in the matte range and 6 shades in the satin finish. The selection was small, yes. But it somehow managed to cater so well to so many different skin tones, with only a couple of shades that would only work on really fair skin tones. Both formulas are pigmented and comfortable and have a sweet scent not dissimilar to MAC Lipsticks. The packaging is black, classy and weighted so you always feel like you're using a more luxury product, which is such a treat.


soap and glory cinnamon beige lipstick review


The new Soap & Glory Sexy Mother Pucker Lipsticks come in 3 finishes - satin, matte & shine - and a whopping 24 shades separated into 3 colour categories - Nudes, Pinks & Reds. It sounds great on paper but I really struggled to find even 2 appealing shades that might work on my skin tone. And worst of all, my beloved Naked Beige and all the other wonderful shades that had such broad appeal seem to have been scrapped (except for Super Nude I believe) for a plethora of very similar, mainly lighter lipstick shades. It's very confusing and heartbreaking all at once. Soap & Glory do claim however that there are still dupes of the original shades in the new line up and they're happy to help you identify which one you need to get your hands on in its stead. 


Soap & Glory Naked Beige vs cinnamon beige
Old Vs New
Naked Beige & Cinnamon Beige


best soap and glory lipstick naked beige cinnamon beige NC40 swatch
Top: Cinnamon Beige
Bottom: Naked Beige

I chose Cinnamon Beige and I kid you not when I say, I prayed this was Naked Beige in new packaging and a matte formula. It isn't. It's close but not quite. Naked Beige is an intriguing nude shade on me, all pinky and brown in beautifully balanced measure. Cinnamon Beige is a brown with a hint of pink, and although it comes across quite similar to Naked Beige on my lips, it's lacking the pigmentation that the previous formula boasted and the alluring depth of Naked Beige. I find myself needing to layer this twice, even thrice in an attempt to cover my hyperpigmented lips. 


new soap and glory lipsticks swatches


Both shades I picked are matte. The formula itself is creamy and comfortable and not drying or tugging. If they had been a lot more pigmented, I think I would feel less deflated right now. Personally I won't be wearing Berry Kissable because it is too bright for me but I can see myself getting a lot of use out of Cinnamon Beige

Onto the packaging, and while I don't believe there was anything wrong with the old packaging at all, I really love the new tubes. Shiny, bright and all round sexy, they've definitely come more in line with the fun side of Soap & Glory. I love the rose gold shade selected for the Nudes line (who doesn't love Rose Gold?!) and I just wish there were more shades that called to me as I would love to line these gorgeous bullets up and just stare at them all day. 


best soap and glory affodable drugstore lipstick


Overall, I'm quite happy with Cinnamon Beige and will be using it a lot and I definitely will try to go in-store at some point and have a proper swatching session myself to see if there are any other shades I might actually enjoy. Until then, I'll carry on savouring the last bits of Blush Pink, Perfect Day and the prematurely discontinued though it makes no sense Red My Lips


drugstore lipstick soap and glory


Have you tried these new Soap & Glory lipsticks? How do you find they compare to the originals? What was your favourite shade? Which shades are you drawn to how? Let me know...



You may also enjoy reading: Best Of Soap & Glory Makeup


Sal xxx

You Might Also Like

20 comments

  1. Have never tried the original! But the ones you have look like they are the perfect everyday shades :)
    Kathy x
    www.alongcamekathy.blogspot.co.nz

    ReplyDelete
  2. This new packaging is everything! <3 <3 <3

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh what a shame :( it's so annoying when that happens.
    I've got one of the originals in Pom Pom and it looks like that's been discontinued too x

    Rhi | www.rinkydinkyrhi.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. I hate when brands discontinue products/shades :( I felt the same about Nudist in the gloss stick range, the new version is a lot more brown toned! I like the few of these that I have but my local Boots has the worst selection ever so I'm not sure I'll pick up any more!

    Danielle's Beauty Blog

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ooooh they changed Nudist too? The original didn't show up on me at all so maybe I should give the new one a go? xxx

      Delete
  5. I never got round to trying the originals, although i've heard they're greatly loved! I personally like the new line. Cinnamon Beige being my favourite. I wonder if i'd feel the same if i'd tried the originals xx

    LPage Beauty

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ignorance is bliss as they say ;)xxx

      Delete
  6. The reason I asked u earlier whether these are comparable or not was to pick my order from store or return it straightaway. haha, I did return all 3 shades I picked.. Even though these were at offer price when I ordered but I really like the original formula. I'm quite happy with Naked Beige, blush pink and pom pom from original line and have backups for Naked Beige. Wish I could try perfect day as well but nevertheless Naked Beige is pigmented enough to cover dual toned lips without overpowering.
    Have a lovely week ahead darling 😘
    Ash | www.mstantrum.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh gosh! You should have kept them and tried them out hun. You might've liked them. Those shades are my absolute fave...its a shame you didnt get to try the beauty of Perfect Day. I'm hoping there's a new version of it hiding somewhere in the new line xxx

      Delete
  7. The reason I asked u earlier whether these are comparable or not was to pick my order from store or return it straightaway. haha, I did return all 3 shades I picked.. Even though these were at offer price when I ordered but I really like the original formula. I'm quite happy with Naked Beige, blush pink and pom pom from original line and have backups for Naked Beige. Wish I could try perfect day as well but nevertheless Naked Beige is pigmented enough to cover dual toned lips without overpowering.
    Have a lovely week ahead darling 😘
    Ash | www.mstantrum.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. The packaging has to be one of the main selling features for these lipsticks, they're beautiful!
    Charlotte // www.charlottespicks.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, the packaging is beautiful :) xxx

      Delete
  9. I feel like the new lipsticks are very same-y and I agree they're all really light :( I'm gonna miss Perfect Day

    Jasmine xx

    Jasmine Talks Beauty

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know right...I'm yet to swatch in store so I'm still hoping the original shades are hiding there among the new ones. :) xxx

      Delete
  10. OMG I'm digging the new packaging. So stunning. I have never tried the original formula. But now I'm curious to try some lipsticks from Soap and glory. Wish they were readily available here in States

    Sam || Beautydetour

    ReplyDelete
  11. Which of the new ones would you say is closest to Perfect Day? Helen

    ReplyDelete
  12. I am so glad I found this blog! I have been having a near breakdown. I spent an hour 'swatching' in Boots today. Naked beige is also the only lipstick I have used in its entirety and I wear it everyday for every occasion. I've never known a lipstick like it, perfectly balanced. The nearest is cinnamon beige but still not as good. I have tried every other makeup range as well, to no avail. I never imagined I'd ever feel like this about a lipstick ��

    ReplyDelete

Thank you so much for reading my post and taking the time to leave a comment. I read every single one :)

If you would like to reach me for a more direct response, please feel free to contact me on: ummbabybeauty@gmail.com

Thank you,

Sal xxx